Hi Peter,
Sorry about the mix up of names

it is meant to be Whitby, thats the trouble when you research more than one name at a time.
Thank you so much for your help on James Whitby. It's very strange though, because I have an 1861 census on hs family which reads:
Ellen wife 45 born on Chester Flatman's wife
Joseph son 17 Ellesmere Port
Mary dau 15 "
Jane " 12 "
George son 10 "
William " 24 Chester
I know James (father), James (son), Eliza and Thomas aren't on it but the places of birth differ too, which one do you think is right?

Regards,
Jill.