Here's my thoughts on my Mysterious Great Aunt Winnie (in order of my most likely)
1) Winnie / Winifred Frader was her real name and I just haven't been able to find her - maybe she wasn't born in Britain
2) She anglicised her name - maybe early in 1914 she didn't think it a good idea to have a foreign sounding name
3) She could have been married and widowed prior to marrying Johnny in 1914
4) She changed her name for some reason and didn't want her background to be known
The marriage certificate may help if her father's name is there and any witnesses may help if there was a connection to Winnie but I'm not banking on it.
Johnny Basham was very well known so it could have been a good enough reason to change her name as he was in court twice just before they maried (In Dec 1912 a woman punched him in the ear after seeing him with another woman (Probably Winnie) and then in Sept 1913 the woman that hit him in Dec 1912 unsuccessully sued him for child support)
I'm hoping her father is recorded on the marriage certificate and that any witnessess do give a clue for me to follow up. If not then it's more likely she did want to hide her background, and I'll repost here with the info on the marriage cert once I have it.
SS, are you saying that Edith Winifred may have made up a new name for herself, Frader, and commited bigamy?
Possible of course, but would she then actually say her father was called Elias when she married Johnny Basham? 