Florence Hall born London 1883

[Sally4x]

Are there then two Henry Philip Halls? And the one I found is wrong? Their jobs are certainly different.

[softly softly]

Spent a little time searching the 4 Henry Philip Hall born between 1857-1868.

1. 1857 Reg dist Chertsey mmn Brooke (should read Brooker. He appears with parents James Anthony & Susannah in 1871/81 census and by 1900 is with parents and siblings in Cambridge Ward 4, Middlesex, Massachusetts.

------------------

2. 1864 Reg Dist Bromyard mmn Lawrence (should be Lawrance) With parents Henry & Maria in 1871/81. He marries Rhoda Rogers 1888 Fulham
Dau Elizabeth born 1888-1888
Son David Samuel born 1890-1890

1891 ref 36 155 35

dau Rosetta Mary born 7.6.1893

1901 ref 1627 116 31

Cannot find any of them after 1901 census.

----------------------

3. 1868 reg district Bromley--mmn Stratton

Sadly dies 1881 Bromley aged 12.

_________________

4. 1864 Reg Dist Pancras mmn Robson. His mmn varies between Robson & Robertson . Parents Alfred & Annie Edith Robertson

Details known for him in 1871/81 and then marriages and death. Except for 1921
__________________

Number 2 needs further research.

SS

[Sally4x]

Thanks  - I did as well and Henry Philip number 2 is in Aston Warwickshire with his parents on the 1881 census. He is a glazier like his father. After he marries in 1888 in Fulham he is in Hammersmith on the 1891 census working for an ironmonger.

Henry Philip number 4 seems to be the best option because he is also in the right area of London.

Neither of them are travelling and selling tobacco though. Of course Jane could have put an entirely made up name down on the birth certificate, but if Henry Philip Hall is correct I am thinking it is number 4.

I hate it when I never manage to get all the answers, but thanks for all the help.