I appreciate what you are saying but for those trying to help it is handy to have all the information in one place

Well he is consistent from 1851 that he was born in London, Middlesex. I wonder what took him to Portsea, did the family move there, or maybe he was not bn in London but the family moved there when he was a young child. It is always difficult to define exactly where in Middlesex someone would consider 'London' to be as it stretches out further than the central areas that you are currently looking at.
Presumably there are no pension records available for him.

Have you done your DNA
