Hi Monica. I am not a football historian but I have some information which may help or confuse you. 
There was a Charlie Tully who played for Celtic born in Northern Ireland in 1924 and died in 1971.
Also a James Tully born in 1883 and died in 1949 who was an English footballer. Played for a variety of teams including Rochdale and Clapton Orient.
All the above comes from Wikipedia.
Wish I could read some of the other names on the bottom
Not very helpful am I and hope someone else comes along who has more knowledge of football.
Dorrie.
P.S. My family all support Hibernian going back generations. I wonder why your father supported Celtic??
I'm a Hibs supporter too, and have passed the virus on to one of my sons, although the other one supports Hearts.
There's a nice story about Charlie Tully. The queen was riding through Glasgow in an open carriage and Charlie Tully was sitting beside her. A voice in the crowd was heard to say, "Who's that sitting beside Charlie?"
Harry