Author Topic: FTDNA test for mtDNA  (Read 683 times)

Offline dtlroots

  • RootsChat Extra
  • **
  • Posts: 84
    • View Profile
FTDNA test for mtDNA
« on: Sunday 28 May 23 17:04 BST (UK) »
I am contemplating taking the mtDNA test (and possibly the mid-range Y-DNA test as well), and would welcome feedback from those who have already bought them on a couple of aspects.

Firstly, regarding the cost, they are currently priced at USD 159 and USD 249 respectively. Does FTDNA ever offer discounted prices, as Ancestry and MyHeritage routinely do? Presumably there are added shipping costs. Does anyone know what they are? (I am in the UK).

Regarding the mtDNA test and its potential usefulness, my maternal direct ancestry as far as I know is all based in Anglesey. Having been researching fairly enthusiastically for about 18 years now, I am still unable to get back with certainty any further than G3 grandparents.

Those of you with Anglesey ancestry will understand the difficulties involved - the very frequent occurrence of the same few surnames and the relatively closed community of the island, meaning that DNA matches seem to be very commonly connected on more than one line.

My hope is that an mtDNA test might identify some known autosomal matches as being on the direct maternal line. I suppose a problem might be that the database of mtDNA matches on FTDNA is presumably much smaller than the number of people on the autosomal test databases.

I would be interested to hear any feedback on how useful people have found the test in identifying how matches are connected.

Dave
Leek - Salford/Radcliffe/Shropshire
Gaut - Shropshire
Harrison - Burntwood Staffordshire
Dutton - Tarporley, Cheshire
Hayes - Forton/Preston
Corbett - Coleshill
Wareing - Forton, Woodplumpton Lancashire
Bonser - Leicestershire
Hughes - Amlwch, Rhosybol, Parys Mountain, Cauldon Lowe
Williams - Amlwch
Thomas - Llaneilian, Llanwenllwyfo
Dodd - Shropshire

Offline hdw

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,047
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: FTDNA test for mtDNA
« Reply #1 on: Tuesday 30 May 23 21:07 BST (UK) »
I tested my mtDNA and Y DNA with FTDNA and also did their Family Finder (autosomal DNA) test.

FTDNA found me 25 mtDNA matches - 11 of them were at a genetic distance of 1 from me, 10 at a distance of 2 and 4 at a distance of 4.

My haplogroup is J1c2.

My earliest known mtDNA ancestor was an Ulster Presbyterian woman with a Scottish surname in Co. Down, Northern Ireland, and interestingly enough several of my mtDNA matches also had an earliest known female ancestor from that area. I also had several matches whose mitochondrial ancestry went back to Norway. Some of these people were Norwegian and some Norwegian-American. You will gather from this that I managed to correspond with some of my matches, who turned out to be quite well informed about their family-tree.

I think I can tie the Northern Irish and Norwegian strands together. The geneticist Stephen Oppenheimer wrote a book called "The Origins of the British" in which he has a map showing movement of what he called J1b people from Norway over to Scotland in the Neolithic. Those Norwegians who stayed at home would obviously have similar DNA to some of their distant cousins in Scotland. In the early 1600s the  so-called Plantation of Ulster saw thousands of Scots, mainly from the west of the country, moving over to Ulster, and many of them might have had very distant ancestry from Norway. Also - of course - in historical times Norwegian Vikings raided the west of Scotland, took women home to be their wives, while others stayed here and became Scots.

Harry

Offline dtlroots

  • RootsChat Extra
  • **
  • Posts: 84
    • View Profile
Re: FTDNA test for mtDNA
« Reply #2 on: Thursday 01 June 23 19:50 BST (UK) »
Thanks for the feedback, Harry.
I think I will give it a go.

Dave
Leek - Salford/Radcliffe/Shropshire
Gaut - Shropshire
Harrison - Burntwood Staffordshire
Dutton - Tarporley, Cheshire
Hayes - Forton/Preston
Corbett - Coleshill
Wareing - Forton, Woodplumpton Lancashire
Bonser - Leicestershire
Hughes - Amlwch, Rhosybol, Parys Mountain, Cauldon Lowe
Williams - Amlwch
Thomas - Llaneilian, Llanwenllwyfo
Dodd - Shropshire

Offline cbowley

  • RootsChat Extra
  • **
  • Posts: 30
    • View Profile
Re: FTDNA test for mtDNA
« Reply #3 on: Thursday 01 June 23 23:02 BST (UK) »
My mtDNA came out as K1a4a1a3 plus three extra mutations in the HVR2 region. I already knew it was K1a4a1a from a 23andMe test some years ago so the single additional letter didn't add much. There were 33 matches. Of the 3, 0-distance matches one was from the Yorkshire/Nottinghamshire/Lincolnshire area, another from Germany and the third didn't give any location information. Eupedia says it has been found in Germany, Britain and Ireland so that checks out. I've traced my maternal line back to Upper Clatford, Hampshire in 1801.

Most of the matches give little geographical information. Interestingly, two of the 2-distance matches list the same woman as their earliest known maternal ancestor but she is in Pennsylvania and at 2-distance the MRCA would be a thousand or so years back.

It was interesting to satisfy my curiosity but has yielded no assistance in breaking through my maternal line brick wall.

I know your pain with Anglesey genealogy. I did a tree for a friend, a Jones with his paternal line from around Amlwch. Once you get beyond the census years it becomes impossible to distinguish couples that have the same exact names getting married in the same year in the same place.
Bowley - Leicestershire/Nottinghamshire.
Cooper/Lungley - around the River Blackwater in Essex.
Austen - Kent
Haspinall - London
Judd/Perren - Wiltshire
Manfull/Thirtle/Cannell - Norfolk/Suffolk