Maddy, a huge thank you and yes you have found my Solomon. The 1910 census shows he is English whilst the first gives his authenicity as Canadian and the next one American. I guess someone completed the form for him? In the 1910 census it gives his occupation as City something?
At sometime it would be good to track down his death, occupation and marriage and thanks to your help it should be possible. In 1865 his brother Clement emigrated to Montana, again in the north and having travelled all that way you would have thought they would live close. His brother became a rancher so there might have been more opportunities for him to go somewhere else.
Thank you again, Mark