working from the info in the opening post, I think we might need to start from this 1891 entry from Attercliffe cum Darnall, Sheffield district ? [as per Ancestry]
William Whitehead 41 Head b "Earby Common" Warwickshire
Lucy Whitehead 51 Wife b Sutton Bonnington, Nottinghamshire
Edward Whitehead 17 Son b Wincobank
Fanny Whitehead 14 Daughter b Wincobank
John W Whitehead 12 Son b Wincobank
RG11; 4616; 78; 54;
That links to Comberton's 1881 suggestion
www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:Q27Y-HXYV The address shown on Ancestry is Low Wincobank
Wife's name is different