There's a Thomas Goodrich bpt at Wilbarston 28 Nov 1759 the first child of Thomas & Sarah, followed by Mary 1761, Sarah 1762, John 1764, Elizabeth 1770, Mary 1773.
Thomas Goodrich wheelwright married Sarah Watts 24 Oct 1758 at Wilbarston by Licence.
A Sarah Goodrich buried 24 Apr 1771 at Wilbarston.
[The marriage you mention to Hannah Cleaver was also at Wilbarston 1772 (??)]
BT entries for Sarah Watts at Wilbarston both 4 May 1728 and 4 Feb 1741. No sign of Thomas Goodrich there.
(Northants Baptism, Marriage, Burial Indexes)