Obit Rose GORMAN 1911 “ran the Shamrock with help of Family”
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/121484257 1907 Archibald COLVILLE is farewelled. He has been in Grahamstown for about 7 years, but the news item’s author chooses not to mention anything about a wife or son.
So guardianship for the child is given to his dead wife’s sister Rose MORRISON nee GORMAN. It’s been stated she has this guardianship in 1912, which is several years after his father’s departure. This Rose (etta) had married John MORRISON ( in 1905), who was at that time proprietor of the Shamrock Hotel at Grahamstown and continued this role at least to 1914 -see Sands Directory 1914 and this item.
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/104355059 The license changed over in June 1915 after which the MORRISONS left for Myrtleford Vic
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/122197991 A death notice for Rose MORRISON in Victoria, makes no mention of Archibald, her sister’s child.
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/206410023.
So Archibald (senior) goes to Emmaville in 1907 presumably as a single man, and one line of thought is-
By 1913 he has turned south and traveled about a 1000 kilometers to Yackandandah where he marries Violet WATERSON in 1913. She dies in 1915, apparently without children.
In Mem 1916
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/144792776 The licensee of the Shamrock Hotel in June 1933 was A (T Possibly a misprint of F) COLVILLE. He was a married man. This item explains the ins and outs of some family relationships.
Hotel ceases trade and there is a case for compensation of concerned parties.
https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/224987748 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/223079885 So one wonders whether Archibald the younger ever left Grahamstown between his guardian's departure for Victoria and his marriage .
One line of thought continues that Archibald COLLVILLE (snr) moves to Greymouth and marries again to Hannah GOSLING in 1917. This man died there in 1954 aged 78 years and his MI at Greymouth Cemetery mentions no others.
So the question is-
All of the above is correct
Some of the above is correct, if so which bits?

Sue