Hi Valk
Glad you have contacted me because I have, so far, been unable to make the connection between james the witness and the William/Hannah marriage. IT might help firm up earlier generations for me. Do you know how they fit together?
I hadn't spotted signature differences and this does raise a doubt. My conclusion was based upon several later documents concerning Abraham that record William as a bricklayer. The other William B in Mobberley at the time was in the horse business.
If you don't mind me asking, how do you fit into the illustrious Blackshaw family line?
Rod