There was a death announcement for Ananias but it doesn't give any more info unfortunately.
Stroud Journal
01 May 1875
page 4, column 1
Deaths
Phelps - March 19, at Bengal, India, aged 22, Corporal Ananias Phelps, son of Amos Phelps, of Chalford.
And in case you hadn't seen this earlier item...
Cheltenham Journal and Gloucestershire Fashionable Weekly Gazette
07 Jul 1866
page 8, column 2
Stroud
Petty Sessions
- Ananias Phelps, aged about 13
- Jacob Gardner, aged about 13
- summoned for having thrown down part of a wall at Bisley
- property of Mrs Camm
- on 23 June
- boys pleaded guilty
- boys said to be of good character
- fined 6d each
Stroud Journal
30 Jun 1866
page 5, columns 1&2
[same story as above but with some additional general info]