Hello
I am the Great Granddaughter of Henry Grundy BRATLEY (Brumpton).
You have made quite a lot of progress in figuring out the Bratley /Brumpton family - it is confusing!
What is your connection to HGB?
The following may clarify things.
Henry Grundy Bratley was the illegitimate son of Emma Brumpton (later Hurd/Hird). He was born 14 Feb 1868 at KIDGATE, LOUTH. His birth was registered as BRUMPTON. I have an original copy of his birth certificate issued in 1902. We do not know the name of his father.
Emma Brumpton was the daughter of Mary Ann & William Brumpton. Mary Ann's maiden name was Bratley. Following William's death, Mary Ann married David Bratley. [prepare yourself fo more confusion] Not only was the groom called David Bratley, but the father's of both bride and groom were also David Bratley!
On the 1871 census Henry Grundy BRUMPTON was living in Binbrook in the household of David & Mary Ann BRATLEY where he and Caroline BRUMPTON & John William BRUMPTON were recorded as 'grandchildren'. By 1881 all three children were still in this household but were then called BRATLEY and were listed as children of the head of the household - David BRATLEY.
When Henry Grundy BRATLEY married Frances (Fanny) Elizabeth HIRST in Sheffield in 1896 he gave his father's name as David BRATLEY (deceased) Grocer & Draper. Henry G was now a Grocer & Draper himself and was running the shop in the market place in Binbrook. They lived first in Binbrook but returned to Sheffield a few years later.
Caroline BRUMPTON/BRATLEY was also the daughter of Emma BRUMPTON and so Henry's half sister (or full sister if she shared the same father). Caroline married a NATHANIAL BRATLEY.
John William BRUMPTON/BRATLEY married Fanny HIRST's sister. John was not the son of Emma, but of Ann BRUMPTON and so I believe these men cousins not brothers (unless they shared a father). However, it was always said in the family that 'two brothers married two sisters' . So did they even know their own birth status?
I have much more on the family and we do have a photo of HGB, but that is probably enough for now!
Please do let me know what your interest in HGB is and I hope we will be able to share more info in future.
Karen