Annie, I did find out who Agnes Hay was. I hope this is the Agnes you were referring to, not Agnes Gray?
Agnes Hay was born 31 March 1850 and baptised 5 May 1850 at Uphall, West Lothian, Scotland to william Foster and Janet Mair.
Agnes Foster first married David Crichton on 6 December 1882 in the Registration District of Newington, City of Edinburgh – 6 Viewforth Terrace, Edinburgh. David's parents David Crichton General Labourer and Margaret Crichton MS Thomson, both deceased. David who married Agnes was listed as a Maltman on Agnes' death registration.
Following David's passing Agnes Foster then married Robert Hay on 7 June 1894 in the Registration District of South Leith – 6 Dickson Street, Leith. Robert Hay's parents were Robert Hay Railway Servant and Jane Hay MS Stevens, both deceased. Robert Hay was listed as a Railway Foreman on Agnes' death registration.
Agnes Hay passed away 9 December 1939 at 27 Constitution Street, Dundee. Her usual place of residence was Farview, Blebo Craigs, Fife. The informant was John Murray, Nephew, Fairview, Blebo Craigs, Fife.
After finding this information and obtaining Valuation Rolls for between 1921 and 1936 Agnes Hay actually resided at Fairview Cottage, not Ayton Cottage.
Armed with this information I then went looking to see if I could locate anything to do with Ayton Cottage. I came across a gentleman Isaac Newton (retired) living there. The proprietor of the property was Joan H. Laing, sylvan Cottage, Kinross the first instance I located was 1925 – 1925. By 1930 Valuation Rolls Mary Newton, was living at Ayton Cottage and continued until the 1940 1941 Valuation Rolls. I did not go further with these as by this time Maggie Gray / Hay had passed away.
So all in all Agnes Foster / Crichton / Hay is totally discounted from the family history for Maggie. The biggest where was Maggie between 1895 until she died still is a mystery. However, did she actually reside with Mary Newton or perhaps the informant on Maggie's death registration give the wrong address. The informant was Maggie's sister-in-law so this will be a brick wall until further evidence can be located.
It has been an incredible journey with finding Maggie and what happened to her. As I have said before it certainly was a labour of love to bring her home.
Kind regards
Judi
In relation to the Cullen family I will get back to you with the information, once I get some of it sorted. I will PM you with this as it is not applicable to the Fife Forum. It may take a week or so as I am still trying to follow down some leads.