... However the Robert I have is Robert Adam JARVIE not Robert Hall JARVIE on the Baptisim and in 1861 census.
Apologies Glenda, the birth record I suggested you look up on Scotlands People was for Robert ADAM Jarvie ( I typed HALL in as middle name in error). That birth certificate should have the birthplaces of the parents recorded and might help establish if John Hall Jarvie was the one baptised in Sheffield.
The father of Andrew Jarvie has died before the 1851 Census. So it is going to be difficult to establish who his parents were.
Looby
