Hi Ruskie
Agree wholeheartedly with both your sets of comments! He seems to impose his feelings about various situations as if they were fact - For example we were told that there was no police force but in the next breath how harsh it was for the two boys to be up 'before the beak'. How do we know that the boys were not part of some 'Fagin' like gang (as in Oliver Twist!) perhaps this type of larceny was rife in the area! They may have been caught before and let off with a warning (btw - the lad probs had a better life in Tasmania!)
I waited to see whether there were any other posts on this topic as I had a few in a row. But since no one else has posted ...
In large part inspired by this programme and also Josey who also has umbrella makers in the family, I decided to do a bit more googling. Umbrella making was by no means a monopoly but one famous maker was James R Smith and there is still a Victorian umbrella shop bearing the name in New Oxford Street, London which is a landmark I used to pass on myway to work. So I did a google and found a history
https://lapada.org/art-and-antiques/gentlemans-walking-stick-1/‘In 1830 James Smith founded the famous firm of James Smith and Sons at Foubert Place in London’s West End. His son moved the business to New Oxford Street in 1857; he also opened six other businesses including a hatter’s and a barbershop. He had eight sons and a daughter, and when he moved to
Tasmania with two of his sons to take up farming, he left the others to run the business at home. In 1930 it was his grandson Mr Mesger (great grandson of the founder) who moved back from Tasmania to take over the running of the business.’
Allied with this:
‘https://www.european-umbrellas.com/umbrella-history.html
‘Due in some part to tariff-free raw materials from its colonies, England was able to produce inexpensive umbrellas - with production costs often below a penny. In Charles Dickens’ novel "The Pickwick Papers" voters in Eatonswill were bribed with expensive gifts for their wives in the form of "45 green umbrellas for seven shillings and sixpence".’
And finally in Tasmania itself
https://www.nationaltrust.org.au/places/old-umbrella-shop/Looking up the Shott family who opened up the umbrella shop in 1920, I found they previously made hardwood souvenirs and Tasmania is famed for its huge hardwood forests.
I did wonder whether, although the manufacture of umbrellas was not a monopoly, the export of wood from Tasmania was in the hands of only a few families?