Are there no tithe records before 1850? Have you looked at maps which go with tithe records?
The Genealogist has address search option too. I'd begin a census search by looking for the name of the road. If that fails, browse the census for the village. Read the page describing the area the census collector was responsible for.
Browse parish registers, looking for entries with addresses.
Leases in county archives. Manorial records.
Local directories. Whoever was resident at the Dower House in 19thC might be listed. There wouldn't have been many people in a village listing in early 19thC, so easy enough to browse.
Local newspapers for family announcements, obits, notices of property sales and leases, news items about social functions, old photos.
Local or county library for newspapers, photos, old guidebooks.
Local history/heritage society.