can anyone help please

[Rosinish]

we have a birth registration for his sister Barbara born 1st April 1884 linlithgow dalmeny

Birth registration 

This implied you had a birth cert. which doesn't help people trying to help if they don't actually know what source you're using i.e. not a birth cert. but something else.

It's always best to quote what you actually have to further your research 

Annie

[Ladyhawk]

The birthdate of George S Hall in the 1939 register ( with wife Alice F)  matches that on the 1970 death of George Sinclair Hall found by Ladyhawk and also the date on the 1886 Dalmeny birth certificate for George Sinclair.

for info.

Probably death for George’s wife Alice, the cemetery section and grave number are the same as for the 1970 death entry for George Sinclair Hall

Alice Florence Hall age 83
Burial Date:   18 Jan 1973
Burial Place:   Manchester, Greater Manchester, England
Cemetery:   Gorton Cemetery
Cemetery Section:   G
Grave Number:   216
England & Scotland, Select Cemetery Registers, 1800-2016

On death registration index gives Alice's dob 4 Nov 1889,

If you search FreeBMD there are other Hall births registered in Chorlton/Manchester S
with mmn Whaite between 1916 - 1934

[Shar10]

thank you for your time in getting me the info most grateful