I have considered these and admit they are very close, but the William that I have doesn't have a middle name mentioned on any of the documents that I have. I'm surprised that the army didn't include a DOB on any of his records, I only looked at Scotland because I couldn't find him here and vaguely remember my Mum saying something about him being Scots. The William in Scotland is William James but his fathers name is wrong, William's fasther was also William. What I would give for a DOB.