There looks to be a good chance that this is 'your' sarah.
RG9/1661 Shepton Mallet Fol 63
Parish : Doulting. (on a Farm)
John Hodges Junr abt 1819 Doulting, Somerset Head
Anne Hodges abt 1833 Doulting, Somerset Wife
James Hodges abt 1858 Doulting, Somerset Son
Annie Hodges abt 1860 Doulting, Somerset Daughter
John Hodges Senr abt 1786 Doulting, Somerset Father
Anna Hodges abt 1785 Doulting, Somerset Mother
Sarah Plumley abt 1833 Warminster, Somerset Servant unwed, Dairymaid.
Martha Colborne abt 1846 Doulting, Somerset Servant
Pauline