Dear Graham
Thank you for that. I know we are not alone in our quest, but it will not be easy, unless in one of the census's one of our rellys has the forsight to give the place of origin, rather than just Ireland.
To this end I have searched some of the earlier ones, eg. 1851, as well as I could, without result, and to make it worse my ancestors regarded themselves as English! Apparently, and according to my mother, there was a great deal of discrimination by employers to employ people straight off the boat so to speak. So, they tended to hide their Irishness and accents, especially if they were in business on their own account. My Grannie did not have an Irish accent, for example, and her grandfather was born in Ireland.
I like to think that they would be amused at our very serious endeavors to trace their ancestors! but I wish one or two of them would take pity and give us a hint.
I do wish you every success and if I do get a lead on why they came out early in the century, and from where, I will let you know.
Regards
Pat