Maggie Cameron - Noble - Smith (Toronto and area)

[Rosinish]

1911 - Not where I was looking;

FRASER PETER
1911
52
122/ 3/ 3
Cawdor
Nairn

Annie

[Rosinish]

Just for ref. incase I lose it.

This one is the wrong age but Edit (was getting mixed up again) interesting she's in the same area so going to check the index to see if I can find who she's with.

NOBLE MARGARET
1911
19
122/ 1/ 3
Cawdor
Nairn

Annie

Added...She's with Evan 60 & Jessie 58 (aka Hugh & Janet)  CAMERON

I wonder  ...I think a good possibility it's the same Maggie & I'm curious as to what the relationship is down as?

Aagghh...Just read your post Sara so not THEE Maggie!

[saraslater]

When searching the DNA links, if you click on the tree (if they have that shared), it shows you where their family tree members are born, and in the area, I'm finding a lot of Cants.

[saraslater]

Maggie was in Canada by 1909 and had my grandmother in 1911.

Just for ref. incase I lose it.

This one is the wrong age but interesting she's in the same area so going to check the index to see if I can find who she's with.

NOBLE MARGARET
1911
19
122/ 1/ 3
Cawdor
Nairn

Annie

[bbart]

Sara, does the DNA matching with the Cants mean that your DNA is matching people who have Cants in a family tree (as in, we have to hope they have accurate trees?)

[saraslater]

yes, exactly.... I'd need more. But it seems one close DNA match's father has Cant in his name.

I'm exploring anyhow, I've found no Camerons...

Sara, does the DNA matching with the Cants mean that your DNA is matching people who have Cants in a family tree (as in, we have to hope they have accurate trees?)

[Rosinish]

I have edited  Reply #109

I'm beginning to wonder if 'OUR' Maggie has maybe borrowed someone else's identity along the way?

Good you're getting 'CANT' connections & maybe not too far away from finding the truth 

Annie

[Rosinish]

Sara,

Had to scrub that as I see you have no CAMERON matches 

Mmm...one does wonder for now about that peculiarity.

Does it depend on the type of DNA test you've done as to what connections you get i.e. maternal or paternal or both?

Annie

[bbart]

I'm beginning to wonder if 'OUR' Maggie has maybe borrowed someone else's identity along the way?

We think she arrived in Canada 1909, because there is a close fit match under the Noble name. It really is like she assumed being a Noble, yet once here, no census or directory match at all.  And that attempted border crossing where she was turned back as labelled a criminal.... did she do something wrong and  change her name? Or did she get tired of having the surname Cant plus Cameron plus Fraser, and just decide to go with the more stable family of Angus and Ann Noble.  Gah!

If we manage to solve this, we are all meeting up for a glass  bottle case of wine.