Maggie Cameron - Noble - Smith (Toronto and area)

[Rosinish]

Luckily this seems the only birth in Nairn 1907 with surname Noble...

NOBLE MAGGIE ANN
1907
123/ 52
Nairn

Annie

Added...Aww, poor wee girl has died 

NOBLE MAGGIE ANN
0
1907
123/ 78
Nairn

[bbart]

Scotlandspeople has only one child , surname Noble, born in Nairn 1907.  She is a Maggie Ann Noble.
She also died 1907 

Angus and Ann Ross did have a daughter Margaret born 1875ish.

What I'm wondering is, the Margaret Noble on the ship list/border crossing, is the one in the article, which inadvertently led us to finding the Cameron/Cant Maggie.  Or is it the same person??

We could make a movie out of the lives of these people.

Edit: Annie types faster than I do.

[DonM]

Annie

Look at the headings in the Census the under place/country of birth follow it down.

Don

[Rosinish]

Angus and Ann Ross did have a daughter Margaret born 1875ish.

What I'm wondering is, the Margaret Noble on the ship list/border crossing, is the one in the article, which inadvertently led us to finding the Cameron/Cant Maggie.  Or is it the same person??

We could make a movie out of the lives of these people.

Same question really (in a different way), who is the Maggie Noble in the household of the Camerons in 1911...talk about musical chairs, they don't stay long enough in 1 place to keep track of who is who & who belongs to who 

All we know is 'a' Maggie Cameron or Noble or both  arrived in Canada, 1 of those girls married.
We know everything about before & after now to conclude the middle & it's not an easy task 

Annie

[Rosinish]

Angus and Ann Ross did have a daughter Margaret born 1875ish.

What I'm wondering is, the Margaret Noble on the ship list/border crossing, is the one in the article, which inadvertently led us to finding the Cameron/Cant Maggie.  Or is it the same person??

Same question really (in a different way), who is the Maggie Noble in the household of the Camerons in 1911

I've now viewed that 1911 entry.

That Maggie Noble is not in the household of the Camerons (which I think may be a different couple with same names) but only on the same sheet 

1911

Cotterton Budgate, Cawdor, Nairn

Roderick Noble 53 Wid
John 22 Son
William 16 Son
Margaret 19 Dau
Catherine m 14 Dau

Annie

[Rosinish]

bb,

The Maggie's are 2 separate girls, I have the BC for OUR Maggie CAMERON & does someone not have the birth for Maggie NOBLE?

OUR Maggie CAMERON seems to be using the surname NOBLE at times but which is who?

Which one is on the ship, which one is in Jail, did one or both go to Canada 

Annie

[cosmac]

The 1911 Scottish census for Cawdor, Nairn
At 18 Piperhill is
Peter Fraser, 52, cattleman with wife
Mary Ann Fraser 44 married 20 years - 7 children 7 living
Hugh 18, James, 17, Elizabeth 14, Martha 12, Kate 10 and two Fraser grandchildren
Willie 5 and Lily 2
No Maggie/Margaret in household.

[Rosinish]

cosmac,

It seems the only time Maggie had the Fraser surname was on the census while with her aunt Mary Ann.

Not sure if she used Fraser in Canada & not sure if that possibility has been checked?


Annie

[cosmac]

Trying to pin down the Margaret Fraser in the 1901 census with Peter and Mary Ann.  Is she still in Scotland in 1911 - did she marry there.  Trying to rule her in or out.  On the 1891 Mary Ann had a Margaret Cameron with her.  There are a few Margaret/Maggie Frasers the right age in Nairnshire in 1911 that Saraslater might try buying the records for