Hi Kayla
I'm not suggesting that he was born in other than England.

However, from what I can see, there may have been two sets of parents named "James and Mary" HARGRAVE / HARGRAVES / HARGREAVES, who had a child named John born in Lancashire about the same time (c. 1831).

* Do you or any of the other researchers have say, a birth cert. for one of his children which may confirm the place of birth of (their father) John ?
* There was some mention I thought ?? in your earlier thread about this John having had a previous marriage in Australia ?
* What details about John are given on his 1869 Marriage cert. ? * Who were the witnesses to this marriage ?
~ Lu