That is correct. Charles was born in Philadelphia. The family relocatd to Reading, PA around 1855. Apparently his father John Christian Benz, was unhappy that the church he attended in Philadelphia began holding services in English instead of German. Family members moved freely between Philly and Reading since it was a relatively short train trip. In 1876 the Philadelphia Directory has Charles living with Rudolph Benz. He is listed as a bricklayer. At the time of his death in 1882 he was back in Reading. I am making a guess in trying to determine where Valeria was originally from. Since it appears that her marriage to George Reber involved a family member I assumed that she was originally from Reading, Berks, PA too.