Going back a step or two and thinking about Edward's transportation, is anyone able to explain the following?:
From JM's reply #8:
Edward GAREY, ex John, convicted Lancaster (or Liverpool Quarter Sessions as per another record), Lancs, 10 Jan 1831, 7 years.
Edward GAREY aged 19, 7 years, ex John, assigned to Edward McDowell, Sydney
And from JM's reply #9:
1837 Convict Muster, NSW.
Edward GEARY, aged 19, per Westmoreland 1832, assigned to William BOWMAN, Maneroo. (Maneroo = Monaro)
Similar names, similar ages, similar dates, but different ships and different assignees.
The same lad or two different lads? 
Good question.
Should be two separate men, but …… in following up on Edward McDowell I can see that he went to VDL.
Edward McDowell was meant to be the NSW Solicitor General from late 1831 but he took too long to take up his duties, and ended up in VDL instead. He had arrived on the Bussorah Merchant in Dec 1831.
http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/macdowell-edward-2397 He is famous for defending Martin Cash, “THE” bushranger. Edward McDowell married in 1835 in Tasmania, and Alfred Stephen witnessed that marriage. Alfred Stephen was a Judge of the NSW Supreme Court, and became Chief Justice of NSW, and was a pew holder, next to one of my direct ancestors, at Christ Church St Lawrence, Sydney. So I have gone through my own family papers to see if perhaps there’s a note suggesting the Stephen family took on an Edward GAREY. Alas, no sighting for Edward there.
https://stors.tas.gov.au/RGD36-1-2p197j2k The NSW State Records has Edward GAREY ex the vessel John of 1832 with a CoF 1 May 1839, #39/0641
As I wrote earlier, Should be two separate men, but …… in following up on William Bowman, Monaro Pioneer …. Well of course, look to my avatar ….. A Bowman descendant ….. alas, yet again I cannot find Edward Geary mentioned in any of my own family papers….
The NSW State Records does NOT have Edward Geary ex the Westmoreland at its Convict Index.
http://srwww.records.nsw.gov.au/indexes/searchform.aspx?id=65&new=1 I cannot see how the Westmoreland could have arrived in 1832, it seems to have been launched in that year. I think the first voyage of the Westmoreland 1835, carried male convicts, none with first name of Edward, none with surname commencing with G
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westmoreland_(1832_ship)
So, instead of saying “Good Question” ….. I am upgrading that comment to
“
Excellent Question Ruskie” ….
We need Dundee’s investigative skills to help sort this out.
One of my sources includes the Biological Database of Australia.
http://www.bda-online.org.au/ Cheers, JM
