Why is Sarah's arrival being questioned. Didn't she write a letter home?
May I suggest that the barque
EMPRESS EUGENIE transported only the regiment and their families from Cork, Ireland and if a manifest was lodged on arrival it has not survived or may have been too fragile to transcribe to the shipping arrivals at the Public Record Office of Victoria.
Was the person you spoke to familiar with the 1852 Passenger Act regarding transport between British Colonies? I doubt it.
http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article38460257http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4799831The Argus 4 Nov 1854
November 3. - Empress Eugenie, 653 tons, W. H. Nattress, from Cork 30th July, transport No.104.
Passengers - cabin : Lieut. Le Wise, Admiralty Agent, Capt Atkinson, commanding officer, Capt. Vereker, Acting Paymaster, Lieut. J. R. Palmer, M. C. Saunders, Assistant-Surgeon Rogers, W. H. Paul, H. L. Williams, C. M. Harward, Mrs. J. R. Palmer, and Mrs. Vereker ; ten sergeants, one hundred and sixty-seven rank and file, twenty-five women, and thirty-four children.
Cando