Anything is possible
Shirley Crabtree, Jr (14 November 1930 – 2 December 1997), better known as Big Daddy, was an English male professional wrestler
Short version of Henrietta - Henrie 'Enrie' (Emma or Emie [Emmie}) ? = 'Enrie') for short becomes 'Henry' and maybe baptism is wrong
Enrie sticks and changed to Emy or Amy (Emie-Emily or Emma) because of confusion with Henry
My Gt gran was Mary put down as Harry in 1851 census