Hi,
The Richard Brockie on this 1881 looks to be the most likely candidate -
Richard Brockie 29 b. Smailholm, Roxburgh. Shepherd
Ellen Brockie 30
William Brockie 6
James Brockie 4
Agnes Brockie 2
Joseph Brockie 4 Mo
Bettyfield, Smailholm, Roxburgh
JJ