Many thanks Steve for all your efforts. Italy is a mystery to me, although some years ago I spent a month holidaying in Tuscany and really enjoyed it.
Could they have married somewhere else? Yes it is possible. Most references to the marriage on their children’s birth certificates just say “Italy” for the place of marriage. One goes further to say “Piedmont, Italy” (Vistarini EHL 1855 BC.pdf). It was assumed by family that this was referring to the region of Piedmont of which Fossano is a town. (Fossano being Anna’s place of birth according to her Australian records.) But perhaps we should have read it as the marriage occurring in the town of Piedmont.
Not sure how big a haystack Piedmont (the town) was in the 1850s, but as a regional centre it might not be a small town.
As I think I said before, whether they married in Italy or not is the mystery. They claimed to have married on their children’s birth certificates. But after they split up Annibal acts as if they were married and Anna acts as it they weren’t. Annibal had 10 children with his 2nd partner, but never married her (presumably to not be a bigamist). Anna married in a Catholic church and claimed never to have been married although she had 4 living children. On another occasion Anna claimed on a legal document that the father of her children was dead (which was not true.) On the balance of probabilities I think that they married in Italy, but I don’t have the evidence.
Regards
Steve,
Melbourne, Australia