If you look at what Thomas Brunton says to the minister, his father was not actually refused burial in the kirkyard, but in the kirk itself. At this period there were lots of arguments over burial inside kirks. It had been allowed in the past, but it was felt that the upheaval caused by digging up the floor, especially as more permanent seating was starting to appear, was not acceptable. There was also, in some quarters, a feeling that burial inside was too close to pre-Reformation practices.