Hi there,
NSW ER 1870 MUDGEE
James NELTHORPE, householder, Market Street, MUDGEE
NSW ER 1878 MUDGEE
James NELTHORPE, freehold, Church Street, MUDGEE.
NSW ER 1903 ROBERTSON, polling at Mudgee
NELTHORPE, all of Church St
James, Tailor
Jane Louise, domestic duties
Minnie, domestic duties
Sarah Rose Harriet, domestic duties
Walter James, Church St, Tailor
From NSW BDM seems Jane Louise was married to James, and Walter James was married to Sarah Rose Harriet. So Elizabeth Amy, born 1866 was daughter of James and Jane Louise, so I agree with Sue’s comment.
Cheers, JM