No,,they are the same man  

   I found Thomas Youngs service record,,and on it,,,luckily for us,,it states in red ink,,  "alias Charles Edward Ledgerwood " then in brackets M3059
He enlisted in the Army Service Corps in 1884....served 21 years,,discharged Chatham in 1906...his service was described as Exemplary.He was a Company quarter master Sergeant.  He was awarded the Egyptian medal 1885,,The South Africa medal 1901   with clasps for  Transvaal,Cape Colony,Wittenburg. He was Also mentioned in despatches in 1901.
I wonder if they found out he had enlisted under a false name,,and due to his good service they let him stay in the army...maybe the notation in red ink  (M3059) is a reference to some sort of military inquiry that was held ??   Anyway..makes sense of the strange birth references.  
