florence sophia proudfoot 1893 jumble

[wilrob]

hi
i have florence sophia proudfoot b1893 auckland durham there is a 1901 census with her parents george e proudfoot born durham and florence proudfoot born in london
now the problem i have is on the 1911 census she is with the perry family in liverpool and it states she is the step daughter
thomas franklin and sara franklin now saras maiden name was levi she married a perry then thomas franklin
thomas franklin was also previously married to isabella thorpe
i cannot find where florence fits in there was a marriage of a george e proudfoot to a sara florence perry in durham but i havent looked into that so far i just need to tie florence sophia in and i am getting in a right old muddle any help to unraffle this would be great 

[Cas (stallc)]

Marriages Jun 1892   
PERRY    Sarah Florence         Auckland    10a   267   
PROUDFOOT    George Edward         Auckland    10a   267

Births Dec 1892   
Proudfoot    Florence Sophia      Auckland    10a   244

Census 1901 the family are together. George E age 48, b Durham. Florence 42, b London. Florence dau b Durham age 8

In 1911 Florence b 1893 is stepdau to head, so that makes 'wife' Sarah Florence b London, alias Proudfoot, alias Perry, nee maybe Levi daughter. (Sarah Florence is prob still Proudfoot ?)

Cannot find a marriage for Proudfoot/Franklin in timeframe or suitable death age wise for George E.  So think they are living together and combined family. 

She also has a Perry son with them from poss first marriage as well as dau Florence Proudfoot from second marriage. The rest are Franklin children.

Hope this helps

Cas

[wilrob]

thank you but the problem being i know sarah levi didnt have the florence in it,sarah perry married thomas franklin 1905 toxteth park liverpool
her first husband joseph patrick perry died 1904

someone messaged me asking about thomas franklins wife sarah perry (levi) i wasnt aware sarah had married a thomas franklin this is how this has came about 

[Cas (stallc)]

So do you have Sarah Perry, nee Levi.. and family.. husband Joseph and son Alfred Edward Perry and/or marriage or 1901 census to prove. RE: 1911

Maybe she remarried T Franklin as Perry and discounted the Proudfoot  possibly while still married

The Perry, Proudfoot, Franklin family are together in 1911. Not common surnames together in one household unless history. Step children to head are Perry and Proudfoot, so are the said 'wifes' children.

Do you have the correct Sarah Levi?

Think only way to prove/disprove is to get Florence Sophia birth cert

Regards Cas

[wilrob]

i this lady that contacted me has the wrong sarah perry some how because she would have to of married proudfoot after perry and before franklin
there is proudfoots on the other side of the levi tree and if you look at florence s proudfoot on the 1901 census there is a harry plant ...there also plants in the tree lol there is an emma gustava levi who married an harry plant so there is a connection its figuring it out x

[Cas (stallc)]

I do not follow info as/was given for original request. As have not viewed trees for the peeps you are on about.  Seems to be we are going in circles.

Hope you sort it

Good luck and best wishes

Cas

[wilrob]

  yes cas we are the family just seem to have numerous marriages or partners sarah levi came from a family of entertainers vocalists comediennes etc and just keep popping up everywhere i have e mailed the lady to ask her to double check things thanks for your help x

[Cas (stallc)]

Does not seem to be right family then.

Ok, thanks for info and as said good luck

Cas

[rosie99]

Have you found the other 'step child' on earlier census