Now, here's interesting for you:
I've looked on the Lancashire Libraries on-line 19th C newspapers archive.
For the Princess Royal beerhouse ( Holmfirth but no precise address) there are 3 refs in 1890, 92, 94 all local petty sessions court cases( refusal to quit premises, serving a drunk, being drunk etc), with landlord James Bray named in the 1892 report.
For Rose and Crown ( Holmfirth but no address) there are over 90 refs between 1840 and 1895, court cases, reports of meetings, including Druids, Chartists etc.( I haven't read them all but here are a few:
Flood victims 1852.
On 15/06/1861 the landlord was William Bray. On 15/08/1863 Tedbar Earnshaw died there.
No reports at all in the 1870's.
On 25/08/1890 Arthur Beaumont of R&C won a prize in a dog show!
An inquest was held on 10/10/1890 at the R&C Hotel.
Feb 1895 , a meeting was held there.
So, at least from 1980-94 the PR beerhouse and the R&C Inn/Hotel seem to have existed concurrently.The beerhouse seemingly smaller,more disreputable than the inn/hotel.
The lack of precise address is a bit of a nuisance, I feel.
Will keep digging...