Hi there,
Cando has mentioned that we are discussing pre civil registrations, and I mentioned we are discussing pre separation of the colony of Victoria from the NSW.
The movement of emancipated convicts from VDL to Melbourne is also a significant factor to consider, and of course Civil Registrations for BDM events commenced in VDL before just about anywhere else in Australia, so their records were based on English requirements and are therefore quite scant, whereas VIC and NSW legislation on civil registrations is more akin to Scottish requirements and therefore BDM records are quite detailed. The family history dilemma is when the official records are not civil registrations, and (in the case of NSW BDM) they are based on transmitted Early Church Records, so the usual family history clues in these registers are often obscure or simply not recorded.
May I stress that it is entirely possible that Billy/Harry (William Harry/ William Henry) Simpson was born in Melbourne, but as there was NO civil registration system in existence, so unless he was baptised by a clergyman who recorded the ceremony in his register, and unless that register has been shared with either (or both) the NSW BDM and the VIC BDM then it may not ever be possible to find the birth record that DadLoco is seeking.
May I also stress that while Billy/Harry believed he was born in Melbourne, he may have been recalling that is where his first memories place him as a child, or as an adult perhaps he was answering a question “what native place for thy father” rather than “what native place for thyself” when registering births of his own children. Afterall, that now archaic form of “your” was still part of many religious services until perhaps the 1970s.
DadLoco, do you have any details about your Ada/Aida Ellen’s UNCLES or AUNTS ….. perhaps by looking for likely siblings for her Dad, we may find the names of HIS parents, which afterall is the fundamental quest at present. For example, perhaps Ada kept a birthday book, or a Christmas Card List, or a diary, or a family Bible, or simply letters from her aunts or uncles or first cousins.
Cheers, JM