The 1880 Ohio Census shows the following in Ashland Co.
Hazel, James, 56, farmer, b. OH, DE, DE
Mary, 55, b. PA, PA, PA
James, 17, b. OH, OH, OH
Mary, 17, b. OH, OH, OH
Reuel, 14, b. OH, OH, OH (looking at the census image, it is Reuel but is indexed as Rewel.
The person is also listed as a female, but there are many mistakes in labeling
by the transcribers)
Butson, Earnest, 10, grandson, b. OH, ENG, OH
Ada, 8, grand daughter, b. OH, ENG, OH
-----------------------------------
Ohio Death Certificates 1908-1953
Earnest Hiram Butson
DOB: 17 Dec 1869
POB: Amherst, Lorain, OH
DOD: 17 Aug 1946
POD: Lorain Co., OH
Father: James Butson, b. ENG
Mother: Susan Hazel
-----------------------------------
Ohio Death Certificates: 1908-1953
James P Butson
DOB: 27 Oct 1845
POB: England
DOD: 22 mar 1921
POD: Lorain Co., OH
Father: Butson b. England
Mother: Mary Parkinson b. England