Right, Wdurham,
Time to cut in on the dynamic dialogue you have been having with Bedfordshire Boy. I managed to wriggle myself away from the Xmas shopping (hooray!) in Cambridge today, and shot off to Shire Hall for some respite for an hour. And although I may not have solved all the mystery surrounding the WATSON family, I think I've at least shed some more light on the matter...
Looking first in the transcribed Cherry Hinton registers 1538-1912:
Marriage on 06-05-1806: John WATSON (x) and Elizabeth COOPER (x) b.o.t.p. Witnesses: Mary Linsey and the (ubiquitous) Samuel Mortlock, who must have been a church worthy as he's still acting as a witness for your next WATSON marriage in 1829.
Subsequent baptism: 27-07-1806: John WATSON, son of John and Elizabeth
Then, Marriage on 02-03-1829: John WATSON (x) and Rebecca HARRISON (x) b.o.t.p. Witnesses Charles Cornel and Sam Mortlock
Subsequent baptisms: 10-01-1830: James WATSON son of John (lab) and Rebecca.
08-04-1832: William WATSON s. of John and Rebecca
08-03-1835: Hannah WATSON d. of John and Rebecca.
There was definitely NO 1837 baptism for the family, the only other WATSON one was on 12-01-1834 for Alice WATSON d. of James (lab) and Susan.
BUT, the very last baptism in the book for WATSON was:
31-01-1858: William WATSON, an adult of John and Rebecca of St Andrew The Less, Cambridge, Lab.
Here are some significant WATSON burials at Cherry Hinton:
20-03-1831: John WATSON 54
21-03-1833: William WATSON aged 14 months
08-09-1834: Elizabeth WATSON 57
24-08-1841: George Lyes (?) (this question mark was in the transcription) WATSON of St Andrew The Less, Cambridge, 7 weeks
20-05-1846: Rebecca WATSON of St Andrews The Less, Cambridge, 35
Do you know when the family might have gone to Chesterton Workhouse? (I looked in the Parish Chest for Cherry Hinton, but couldn't find anything). And if this second William was indeed born in 1837, you are really unlucky that they didn't start National Registration until Sept. quarter 1837!
Perhaps the baptismal entry for him indicates that he had just become 21 years of age - "an adult" - on 31-01-1858. I'd like to have an educated guess that he might have been born on 31-01-1837, or very close to that date.
There's more on the WATSON's in the Cherry Hinton registers, which you might already have. I'll have a break now and possibly PM you with those details if you want them.
Interesting that, even though St Andrew The Less is just down the road from the Chesterton Workhouse, Rebecca WATSON was buried back in Cherry Hinton.
Keith
p.s. I looked between 1835 and 1840 amongst the baptisms of St Andrew The Less for William before I realised that we needed his BIRTH, and that I already had a baptism for him at Cherry Hinton! Perhaps I should have stuck to the Xmas shopping...