Part 1.
Wicklow Town Commissioners.
A special meeting of this Board, convened by requisition, was held at 7 o'clock on Monday evening last, in the County Courthouse. The following Commissioners attended:
Dr. Andrew Nolan, Chairman, Messrs. Francis Wakefield, Thomas Doolittle, John Hayden, James W. Dillon, John Chapman, Henry McPhail, John O'Brien, Thomas Smyth, Thomas Troy, and William McPhail; Robert Halpin, Secretary.
The Corporation Land - Allowance For Raw Stubble, &c.Mr Chapman proposed that the tenants should be allowed the first half-year's rent for such portions of their land as is in raw stubble or broken ground.
Mr Wakefield was of opinion that this allowance should only be granted to those tenants paying £4 per acre.
The Chairman - I think it would be well if you would define the fields where the allowance should be made.
Mr Hayden - I think you might confine it to Carr's late holding.
Mr Wakefield - I am under the impression that some gentlemen have been given this allowance in the fixing of the rents. Have any persons been granted land at a low rent because some of it was in raw stubble?
Mr Chapman - No.
Mr Henry McPhail - If I do not make a great mistake I believe a resolution has been already passed that the tenants getting possession in November would not come under rent until the March following.
The Chairman - That has no relation with the question before us.
Mr Chapman - I don't know the reason why Mr Wakefield should put in the proviso that the allowance should be made only to the tenants paying £4 an acre. The resolution I have proposed would take in every person that fell in for raw stubble or broken ground. Among those is Mr James Byrne. If the Commissioners think he should not be granted the allowance I have no objection: but whether they do or not there is another holding which should have the advantage of it, and that is, a part of the field held originally by Mr Byrne which was given to Mr Thomas Doolittle. The broken land on that should have the same advantage as the rest.
(Here Mr O'Brien called upon the Chairman to show him the requisition convening the meeting as it was a special one.)
Chairman - I know that this meeting was called by the unanimous consent of the committee, and at least four of the Commissioners signed the requisition.
Mr O'Brien - But you know you cannot call a special meeting unless there is a requisition for it, signed by at least one-third of the Commissioners. I require the requisition to be produced; our meeting must be legally constituted.
The Secretary Mr Halpin then went for the requisition.
Several Commissioners thought that seven members of the Board had signed the requisition, and that they might go on with the business.
Mr Wakefield - As you wish the business to go on I must say that in my experience I do not know of any books that show more injustice than the books of the Wicklow Commissioners. I consider that lately we have not acted justly and equally, and it shall not go on without my protest.
The Chairman - Mr Wakefield, I must call you to order, because I think you are making a gross attack on the Commissioners, and I am sure you will admit that an attack of that kind should not be made. I must request you to confine your observations to the resolution at present before us.
Mr Wakefield - I am coming to that. Mr Chapman by a series of resolutions has compelled us to commit an injustice which really I am ashamed of. I will tell you what we have done: I believe I proposed that Mr Connor should have his land at 17s 6d per acre. Mr Chapman advisedly -
The Chairman - I must protest against you saying anything about Mr Chapman doing acts 'advisedly'. What he proposed received the full consent of the Commissioners, and if you reflect upon him in that way you reflect upon the whole body. I cannot sit here and allow an individual Commissioner to bring a charge against another for what the whole Board has confirmed, and I must say Mr Chapman's resolutions were framed with an intelligence and zeal which should be commended.
Mr Wakefield - I am just telling you what we have done.
Mr Chapman - You must confine yourself to the business.
Mr Wakefield - We took a piece of land from Mr Connor which was immediately assigned at £2 10s per acre to Mr Fox, one of the most respectable men in this town. The piece of land given to Mr Connor, in place of this, for 17s 6d an acre, is to be taken back and given to Mr Fox at £4 per acre. Now, if you consider that is fair, I am done with my notions of what is fair and right. In the case of Mr Byrne, his land was given at the low rent of £2 an acre because he got raw stubble. I heard Mr Chapman say that himself - I remember it distinctly. In addition to that allowance are we to give him half a year's rent? When you are going to put a £4 rent for bad land on a respectable inhabitant, who has laid out a great deal of money in the town, I have a right to be heard, and I will see justice done. We have passed a lot of resolutions, and after all very probably what we have done will be upset. You have already granted an allowance to Mr Byrne for the raw stubble. Now you propose to give him further compensation.