I can tell you this. Although Brooklyn is a part of NYC, it was isolated until 1883 when the first bridge was built -- the Brooklyn Bridge, opening up a whole new access. However, before that they depended on ferries back and forth. Also, Brooklyn was famous for the Brooklyn Navy Yards, which the U.S. Navy used from at least from 1806 - 1945 (and maybe before) because of its unique position -- close enough yet out of way of Manhattan Island so as not to obstruct, yet have access. I would imagine there would have been a great need for a carpenter on the wooden piers.
Since it's way over whatever # of years NYC requires for a death cert. -- and those are not on line -- they have not yet done the earlier ones -- you could order a death certificate. If you want:
http://www.health.ny.gov/vital_records/death.htm They want $45 to give you a death cert.
I put in an e-mail request with someone who goes down to the NYC archives; let's see what he can do first.