I have Alexander Yorkston (B Larbert 23.5.1814 d. Larbert Jun 1850) married 23.4.1833 St. Cuthberts Leith to Catherine (Kitty) Fair (or Phair), ( b 1808 Edinburgh Parish d Edinburgh 10.9.1887)
Alexander's parents were Alexander Yorkston (b. Falkirk 22.7.1785 d. Stenhousmuir 30.6.1857) and Ann Kincaid (b. Falkirk 21.9.1784-d before c 1857)
How can you be sure that these are the correct parents for Alexander Y who died in 1850? What evidence do you have?
You will see that
lgardner has the son of Alexander Y and Ann Kincaid married to Ann Donaldson. The one married to Catherine Fair cannot also be the one married to Ann Donaldson.
The 1851 census lists at South Broomage Hall, Larbert Alexander Y, aged 36, i.e. born between 31 March 1814 and 30 March 1815, assuming it is accurate, birthplace Larbert, with wife Ann (Donaldson) and family. Note that this one's eldest son is Alexander and his second daughter is Ann, which would fit with him being the son of Alexander Y and Ann Kincaid.
Alexander Y and Catherine Fair's first two sons are John and James. The 1841 census gives Alexander's age as 27, i.e. born between 7 June 1813 and 6 June 1814 (assuming it is accurate) and born somewhere in Scotland but not in Midlothian. Also, an index search of the SP pre-1855 deaths finds one death of Alexander Yorkston in
Edinburgh and none in Larbert.
We all need to get this clarified before we go any further. If
lgardner has the death certificate of the Alexander Y who married Ann Donaldson, this would clinch it.