Hi groom and carol,
sorry to take so long, have been reading all of this and trying to work it though. I have a marriage entry here for Ernest and Clara Bird, just looking again, and see that Ernest's father on that one is Arthur, and also, as you say, middle name of Emmins, which to me looks very likely to be the Ernest Hemmings Andrews that you kindly found for me.
Some of this is beginning to make sense, apart from the 'at sea' birth, I may have to order birth certificate for Ernest Hemmings Andrews to be completely sure, as I am confused now as to whom his natural parents were.

I wonder if he was Fanny's child, brought up by Arthur, maybe his natural father was a sailor?
Thank you so much for all this helpful info

rosiejayne