Hello Magheragall. Are you the same person who emailed me some photos ? I am now starting to pad-out this Tree. I have found marriages for 6 of the sons, but can't find what happened to Albert Forde (Hinds) Mackey. Sarah's first born was William Thomas Carlisle 1862, he was a widower on the 1911 with his mother Sarah (Greenfield), but I can't locate any other record for him. I located one of the sons, Valentine born 1871. He went to USA, he was Valentine on the ships passenger list in 1892, but from then on he has the name James Valentine, at first I thought he was a different person, but have now located his marriage record where his parents are named as Alexander and Sarah. Do you know of any reason why he would take on another name. Regards Moya