Yes the entry on Family Search is correct. His parents were James and Elizabeth, bap 16 Dec 1804. Father at this point a miner. I have had this information for some years but when it is called into question you have to look more carefully and it really has been some fun.
The other person had a baptism in 1810, to different parents, and I actually think this is his cousin.
But the establishing that there had been a first marriage and an son by 1828 to this marriage, makes 1810 possible, but improbable.
I also had a photo of a gravestone that indicates 1804.
The person who had originally given me the basic information, quite some time ago, but I had no way of contacting, transcribes for the OPC. So I did have some confidence that the information was correct.
Thanks and hope you all enjoyed the ride too, as this is meant to be recreation.
