Hi Topas
Having gone over all the post on this, the only other conclusion that I can come to on this, is that Matthew William Hedges was adopted when he was born, and registered in that name, in later life he found out who his birth parents were, and then changed his name to Alfred May, and then used all of his names through out the rest of his life,I think that the clue to this may be in the Civil Service Evidence of Age record.
Margp