Morning all & happy new Year!
1844, that's a bit early.
To be "one of ours" the only Mrs Culmer who would qualify would be Alfred's presumed mother, Annie Culmer, nee Cole, born 24 December 1805 and baptised Bodicote Oxfordshire on 5 January 1806. It is believed that she was the bride of Edward Cullmer, carpenter, baptised St Mary the Virgin, Dover, Kent on 19 September 1810, at his marriage at All Souls Langham Place, Marylebone on 19 April 1830.
The first sighting of this couple post marriage is the 1841 census (HO107/701, Book 6, page11) at Salmon's Lane, Limehouse. Four children, Mary aged 12, George [Isaac] aged 9, [Annie] Susan aged 8 and Alfred aged 6, all born outside the county of Middlesex, were also included.
Edward Cullmer, father of Alfred and his siblings, died at "The Tap, Bull & Mouth Street, London" of "Typhus Fever 14 days Certified" on 6 March 1849. His wife Annie, her daughter Annie Susan and her unmarried [half] sister Lucy Cole, all recorded as Needlewomen, are found living together at Bartholomew Close, City of London, in the 1851 census ( HO107/1526, folio 26, page 44). At this time Annie's son George Isaac is found lodging close by and Alfred is a Draper's assistant in Dover. Elder daughter Mary is believed to have been in service in Marylebone.
So, this is the background of "our Mrs Culmer". In 1844 Annie is married with 4 children, the eldest, Mary, being around 15 and our Alfred being around 9 years old. I tried yesterday to get into the Old Bailey site but without success.
If this is a sighting of Annie Cullmer then this would be new information for me. However, with the address being in Islington, my gut feeling is that this may be one of the brush maker Culmers but I will check this out and report back.
Does the witness Mrs Culmer give her husband's occupation to the court? if so this would likely settle the matter.