Author Topic: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA  (Read 16524 times)

Offline Hammerman

  • RootsChat Extra
  • **
  • Posts: 91
    • View Profile
New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« on: Wednesday 16 November 11 20:13 GMT (UK) »
There's a new series on BBC1 tonight of Who Do You Think You Are? USA version.

Only half hour long though. Tonight director and actor Steve Buscemi.
Greensmith - Greasley, Nottinghamshire; Rigley - Nottinghamshire; Wightman - Nottinghamshire; Lee - Nottinghamshire; James - Berkshire (maybe Gloucestershire); Lyons - London; Harrop - Prestbury, Cheshire; Rockett - Middlesex; Chandler - Lambeth, Surrey (maybe Norfolk); Gates - Middlesex; Clark - Islip, Oxfordshire; Richards - Gouldhurst, Kent; Bent - Redbourne, Hertfordshire; Angel - Throwley, Kent; Coker - Middlesex; Bailey - West Lavington, Wiltshire

Offline Jean McGurn

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,065
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #1 on: Friday 18 November 11 18:27 GMT (UK) »
Have just watched my recording of this show and found it quite interesting but also found it to be very fast compared to the usual WDYTYA programmes. It  looks like they have cut quite a few bits out .

Steve appeared to find his each of his ancestors names first go when I think there may have been other people with the same names. 

I did wonder at the end if perhaps there could be a future film. He could play his own great great grandfather's eventful life

Jean
McGurn, Stables, Harris, Owens, Bellis, Stackhouse, Darwent, Co(o)mbe

Offline didactylos

  • RootsChat Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 148
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #2 on: Friday 18 November 11 19:02 GMT (UK) »
Wasn't impressed. The 30 minute programme was very very staged, results came up fast because they were already all 'fixed'. Prerecorded screenshots. Venues were all completely empty of anyone else. Discussions were clipped and hardly worth having.

What a shame.

Roger
Neilson, Henderson, Stark, O'Hara, Anderson - Lanarkshire
Wilson, Hepple, Leech, Bell, Jenkins,  - Newcastle & Northumberland
Houston - Sunderland

Offline Ray T

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,578
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #3 on: Friday 18 November 11 22:14 GMT (UK) »
I was also surprised that the programme only lasted half an hour. My suspicion is that in the US the programme actually lasts for a full hour with the remaining 30 minutes taken up with adverts. Can anyone confirm?


Offline Winterbloom21

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,006
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #4 on: Saturday 19 November 11 10:34 GMT (UK) »
I too got the feelng that it must have been edited.     There were quite a few threads, I thought, that were left unexplored, and things that were said that remained sort of unchallenged.      For instance, he commented several times on the fact that he found it interesting that thoughts of suicide and depression ran in his family after he found out about his ancestor's note in the bottle.

To me, that note in the bottle read like someone's idea of what a suicide note should say and the whole incident seemed more like a calculated plan to make people think he was dead so that he could do a bunk, which he did.       After he'd deserted his first wife and children, and joined the army (which a lot of men have done in the past to help them 'disappear'), he deserted again twice, making it look like a bit of ahabit.       Again, I smiled to myself when SB said that maybe his ancestor had come back to the army the first time out of patriotic duty because the record read 'reclaimed from desertion'.       Maybe it's me, but I would have just thought that meant he got nicked!

Is it just me?         
Toomebridge, County Antrim: Devlin
Toomebridge and Cavan:  McCormick
Glasgow, Wolverhampton, Shropshire:   Hill
Lurgan Co. Armagh:  Malone, Dumigan, McCourt, McGill
St. Pancras, and Poplar, London: Serjeant, Heald
Brookborough Co. Fermanagh:  Carmichael, Tierney
Staffordshire:  Cook
Isle of Wight:   Parkman
Warwickshire:  Kinchin
Cork: Kennedy, Ahern, Deliere

A British Islander, born Dublin of Irish/Anglo roots. Ancestors have crossed and recrossed the Irish sea in every generation.

Offline didactylos

  • RootsChat Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 148
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #5 on: Saturday 19 November 11 10:46 GMT (UK) »
Its not just you.... in fact the more I think about it the more the programme was a 'feature' for the guy himself rather than what we expect over here.

And yes if he'd wanted to join the war agin he'd have simple reenlisted..... he was caught!

sadly I guess its what the audience ratings over there tell them its what they want.

Roger
Neilson, Henderson, Stark, O'Hara, Anderson - Lanarkshire
Wilson, Hepple, Leech, Bell, Jenkins,  - Newcastle & Northumberland
Houston - Sunderland

Offline Jean McGurn

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,065
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #6 on: Saturday 19 November 11 11:06 GMT (UK) »
I was also surprised that the programme only lasted half an hour. My suspicion is that in the US the programme actually lasts for a full hour with the remaining 30 minutes taken up with adverts. Can anyone confirm?

This would appear to be a logical reason, can't think of any other reason  :)

Jean

 
McGurn, Stables, Harris, Owens, Bellis, Stackhouse, Darwent, Co(o)mbe

Offline Winterbloom21

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,006
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #7 on: Saturday 19 November 11 11:52 GMT (UK) »
You're right, Roger.    I got the definite feeling that there was a bit of forelock tugging going on in the direction of the Big Hollywood Star and there were a lot of things that could have been said but weren't because people didn't dare.

Nobody mentioned the word 'bigamy' either, did they?      Or divorce.     He just left the wife and started up with a new one and nobody asked any questions.              And where did his grandmother's name come from - Vandyne?      There didn't seem to be anybody in the tree above her with that name.    Did I miss something, or was that on the cutting room floor, too!
Toomebridge, County Antrim: Devlin
Toomebridge and Cavan:  McCormick
Glasgow, Wolverhampton, Shropshire:   Hill
Lurgan Co. Armagh:  Malone, Dumigan, McCourt, McGill
St. Pancras, and Poplar, London: Serjeant, Heald
Brookborough Co. Fermanagh:  Carmichael, Tierney
Staffordshire:  Cook
Isle of Wight:   Parkman
Warwickshire:  Kinchin
Cork: Kennedy, Ahern, Deliere

A British Islander, born Dublin of Irish/Anglo roots. Ancestors have crossed and recrossed the Irish sea in every generation.

Offline Jean McGurn

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,065
    • View Profile
Re: New Who Do You Think You Are? USA
« Reply #8 on: Thursday 24 November 11 15:02 GMT (UK) »
There is an artical in the Dec edition of Your Family Tree by one of their regular contibutors, that mentions this series and says that the show is heavy with placement ads which the programme relies on. These appear to be by A******y so I suppose being the BBC they have had to cut them out.

This would explain why the jerkiness of some parts of the show.

Jean
McGurn, Stables, Harris, Owens, Bellis, Stackhouse, Darwent, Co(o)mbe