OK, you seem to have quite a few threads trying to find him  
  
  
 
 Thanks morganllan, for reminding me of my threads over the years (and finding it funny). Sorry if I misunderstand you but are you trying to be helpful or just telling me off for having more than one thread? Maybe a PM would have been kinder.
You can see I have attacked this brick wall from different angles (and Counties) and in my exasperation, thought about asking the question on Roots because it is such a super, 
helpful site.  Each time there has been lots of help and friendly advice for which I am  extremely grateful. 
This last thread has brought forward much information from a helpful Rootschatter but after reading your last reply, I will think twice before asking a question. 
