Hi there,
Do you have a copy or a transcript of Phoebe's marriage or her death ... I am thinking her birth details should be noted on that ... of course the marriage would be information she provided, while the information on her dc would be only as reliable as the informant's own knowledge..
Also, do either of you have the 1883 marriage cert for Rosa B Earle and James S Bevan at Cobar 1883 ...
Cheers, JM.