Oh my goodness MalNZ - that is a lot to take in, I am amazed you could find all of that so quickly!. I have seen some of that so hopefully you can understand why I am so confused. My private detective ability is lacking.
Firstly THANK YOU, yes that is my Thomas on the ladder in that photo. I already had seen the one of him outside the Miner's Arms Hotel (also on that list you gave) but I had not seen the mining one. Fantastic!!
Yes my Thomas is the 85y 1922 one. Yes, he was the mine manager. Yes he went bankrupt in 1883 and also in 1895 (for Miner's arms which then burned down, lets hope he didn't do it!!).
I wonder if the "other" Thomas law could be his father?? My Thomas had a son called Thomas (in the 1880s) so it is possibly a name handed down. I also have a feeling that the Canadian Reef mine could be his - only because both of Thomas's sons - William and Andrew - later went to Canada to mine. Maybe there is a connection with Canada??
I would rule out the grocer/builder. I wonder if that is my Thomas on the ship Hannah?
So many posibilities but not many I can be sure of. Thank you for the time you've put into this for me.
Lynda